Moorepark Mennonite Church changed its name to Moorepark Community Church in 1990-91 and moved from 54002 Wilbur Road to 55701 Wilbur Road in 1992, with the first service in December of that year.

In 1995, Pastor Ken Miller joined Pastor Homer Yoder, the church’s leader since 1975, and they worked in tandem until Yoder’s retirement in 2003. Miller then served as pastor until his death in 2016. Vern “Bud” Granger currently serves as pastor.